Both Muhlenberg tennis teams and 15 of their players received academic recognition from the Intercollegiate Tennis Association.

The Mules were named ITA All-Academic teams for the 2025-26 academic year. To qualify for this honor, the team must have posted a 3.20 or higher team GPA.

In addition, seven members of the Muhlenberg men's team and eight from the women's team were named ITA Scholar-Athletes. To be eligible for this honor, student-athletes must have earned a GPA of 3.50 or greater in the 2025-26 academic year.

The 15 Mules who were honored were

• Caitlin Bestrycki (senior in 2026, psychology major)
• Taylor Current (junior, English and creative writing/film studies)
• Alexandra Downey (junior, English and creative writing/media and communication)
• Owen Dyer (junior, economics/mathematics)
• Kety Gaidamashvili (senior, neuroscience)
• Casey Knipe (freshman, undeclared)
• Charley Madlock (junior, computer science)
• Sydney Madlock (sophomore, physics)
• Connor Michael (junior, mathematics/statistics)
• Ella Pomeranz (sophomore, political science)
• Noah Rodburg (freshman, undeclared)
• Alexandra Roehl (sophomore, media and communication/film studies)
• William Rose (junior, business administration/political science)
• Sam Stein (freshman, undeclared)
• Gabriel Tamarkin (senior, economics)

On the court, the Mule women won nine matches during the year, their most since 2011, while the men won eight times. The two teams combined to go 17-4 in non-Centennial Conference contests.