Fourteen members of the Muhlenberg football team were recognized for their academic and athletic excellence by being named to the National Football Foundation's Hampshire Honor Society.

To be nominated for the Hampshire Honor Society, a player must have been a senior who completed his final year of playing eligibility, attained a minimum undergraduate cumulative GPA of 3.2 or higher, and been a starter or contributor throughout the season.

The Mules who were honored were (pictured above):

Blaze Curry, DL, finance major
Peyton Elliott, LB, business administration
George Europe, S, finance and business administration
Sean Krug, LS, finance and business administration
Dante Mahaffey, QB, finance
Matthew Manning, RB, finance
Marcus McClaine, S, business administration
Francis Pommett, DB, political science
Michael Powel, OT, mathematics
Caden Reph, TE, accounting and finance
Vincent Rispoli, DL, business administration
John Runfolo, WR, finance and business administration
Alex Schafer, DL, business administration
Tom Smid, DL, business administration

Muhlenberg enjoyed an outstanding season on the field in 2025, ending with a 9-3 record and earning an at-large bid to the NCAA Tournament. The Mules defeated Union in the first round, recording a postseason win for the eighth consecutive season, and received votes in both final Division III polls.