The Muhlenberg men's basketball team won its first Centennial Conference championship with an 88-86 defeat of top-ranked Franklin & Marshall on February 25, 1995.
Following are excerpts from an article about the game on its 26th anniversary.
"You had David versus Goliath a little bit," said Matt Henrich '98. "And that made for some pretty good theater."
It surely did. On February 25, 1995, the Muhlenberg men's basketball team toppled top-ranked, undefeated Franklin & Marshall, 88-86, before a packed house in Memorial Hall to win the Centennial Conference championship.
"It's one of the most memorable things in my life," said Ernie Koschineg '95, who led the Mules with an other-worldly 26-point performance, 26 years later.
Goliath was Franklin & Marshall, which lived up to the top billing it had received in Sports Illustrated's Division III preview. The Diplomats came into the game with a record of 25-0, one of five undefeated teams in all NCAA divisions, and ranked first in several national polls. They had outscored their opponents by an average of 21.5 points per game, and their last loss to a CC opponent had come in the 1991 Middle Atlantic Conference playoffs, four years earlier.
Muhlenberg played the role of David. Although the Mules had been successful, they had not won a conference championship since 1970; F&M lifted 11 conference trophies during the same period. Muhlenberg came in with a record of 17-8 but was on a roll. After dropping a pair of games at a tournament at Roanoke in early January to fall to 5-5, the senior-leaden team did some soul-searching and rebounded to win 12 of its next 15, capturing the CC East Division and easily knocking off Western Maryland, 78-54, in the semifinal.
Franklin & Marshall led 9-7 just under four minutes into the first half, but Muhlenberg went on a 10-0 run and maintained its advantage for the remainder of the game. The Mules shot an incredible 16-of-24 from the field (66.7 percent) in the first half and went into the locker room with a 43-32 lead. Koschineg scored 16 points in the first half, making all five of his field-goal tries, including three three-pointers.
It was 84-80 heading into the final minute. Koschineg made one of two free throws but F&M responded with a three just eight seconds later, and now the margin was just two. With 13 seconds remaining, Chris Bedell (21 points) sank a pair of free throws to make it 87-83.
With 4 seconds on the clock, the Diplomats got an offensive rebound, and their All-America point guard Dave Jannetta sank an off-balance three to cut the gap to one.
Michael Queenan was fouled immediately on the inbounds pass and made the second free throw for an 88-86 Muhlenberg lead.
A timeout set the stage for the final Diplomat chance, and on a Mule team filled with seniors – Koschineg, Donny Smutko, first-team All-CC forward Mike Gramer, Michael Rooney, Kort Wickenheiser and Mike Quill – it was two freshmen, Queenan and Henrich, who combined to make the final stop on the All-American Jannetta, who was dribbling down the right sideline.
"Queenan does a great job beating him to the spot," recalled Henrich. "And once he cuts him off, he has no choice but to spin at that point. When he spun, the [ball] was like a grapefruit. He really just kind of put it on a platter for me to knock it away."
Henrich dove on the loose ball as the buzzer sounded, and the Mules and their fans could finally breathe a sigh of relief.
Smutko stood under the basket with his hands on his head in disbelief after the clock reached zero. Henrich, still clinging to the ball, was swarmed by a small group of Muhlenberg fans who had stormed the court. Koschineg, who was on the bench for the final play, skipped to join the larger crowd of court-stormers at midcourt. He would soon be raised on their shoulders.
The good feeling extended well after the game ended, and well past the friendly confines of Memorial Hall.
"That night was probably the greatest night I ever experienced at Muhlenberg," said Koschineg. "I don't think any of us slept that night, but it was fun."
The teams combined to shoot 59.4 percent from the field and were even better – 60.0 percent – from three-point range in the epic championship game.
"It's one of the better basketball games ever played in college," said Smutko.