The Muhlenberg women's basketball team of the decade 2010-11 to 2019-20:

First Team
PG       Brandi Vallely (2015-18)
SG       Alexandra Chili (2011-12)
SF        Alita Zabrecky (2011-13)
PF        Leanna Tallamy (2013-15)
C          Chelsea Gary (2015-18)

Second Team
PG       Kelly McKeon (2011)
SG       Rachel Plotke (2015-18)
SF        Erin Laney (2011-14)
PF        Kate Clawson (2011-13) 
C          Christina Santone (2013-16)
 
Honorable Mention
Sara Dilly (2016-19)
 

---

A three-time All-Centennial Conference first-team selection and two-time All-American, Vallely is the CC all-time leader in assists. Her 655 assists rank 15th in Division III history and broke the school record by more than 200.

Chili earned All-America honors in both years she played in the decade, including a first-team nod in 2012, when she also was an Academic All-American. She is the CC all-time leader in points (2,002) and three-pointers (336).

Zabrecky was a three-time All-CC selection, making the first team as a senior in 2013, and is sixth on the Mules' all-time list with 1,234 career points.

Tallamy earned back-to-back All-CC first-team recognition in 2014 and 2015, receiving All-America honorable mention the latter year.

Gary was the 2018 CC defensive player of the year and earned All-CC honors twice. She ranks third in program history in blocked shots.

The 2010 CC player of the year, McKeon was sidelined with injury for part of her senior year but still earned a spot on the all-region team after a phenomenal postseason.

Plotke is tied for third on the CC all-time three-point list, with a much higher percentage (.443) than anyone else in the top 20, and was a three-time All-CC pick.

Laney (2014) and Clawson (2013) both earned honorable mention on the All-CC team as forwards.

Santone, the program's all-time leader in blocked shots, was named to the All-CC second team as a senior.

Dilly, a guard, was the 2019 CC defensive player of the year.